Oakdale, NY Listings Dining Shopping Leisure Highest Rated Shopping Sayville General Store $$$ 14 reviews Gift Shops (631) 563-7104 44 Main StSayville, NY 11782 Ooh La La $$ 10 reviews Women's Clothing (631) 228-4692 116 Main StSayville, NY 11782 Madison's Niche $ 8 reviews Women's Clothing, Jewelry, Home Decor (631) 750-6566 91A Main StSayville, NY 11782 Smith Haven Mall $$ 203 reviews Shopping Centers (631) 724-8066 313 Smith Haven MallLake Grove, NY 11755 Emma Rose NY $ 2 reviews Women's Clothing, Accessories (631) 791-3242 199 W Main StSayville, NY 11782 Sayville Antiques $$ 6 reviews Antiques (631) 589-4653 136 A Main StSayville, NY 11782 Angela's House Home Store $ 11 reviews Discount Store, Building Supplies, Furniture Stores (631) 730-8758 2052 Rte 112Medford, NY 11763 Remember Yesteryears $$ 42 reviews Antiques, Jewelry, Thrift Stores (631) 654-3052 901 Montauk HwyOakdale, NY 11769 Good Things Long Island $ 2 reviews Accessories, Toy Stores, Bookstores 44 Main StSayville, NY 11782 On a Whim Gift Boutique $$ 6 reviews Gift Shops (631) 650-6483 63 W Main StEast Islip, NY 11730 A Cottage In the City $ 31 reviews Home Decor, Furniture Stores (631) 567-0828 2 S Main StSayville, NY 11782 Paper Doll Vintage Boutique $$ 26 reviews Used, Vintage & Consignment, Women's Clothing, Accessories (631) 319-1919 2 Main StSayville, NY 11782 Bambootique $$ 7 reviews Jewelry, Accessories, Women's Clothing (631) 583-5180 318 Bay WalkOcean Beach, NY 11770 Sun-Vet Mall $$ 19 reviews Shopping Centers (631) 567-6321 5801 Sunrise HwyHolbrook, NY 11741 Flair House $ 2 reviews Women's Clothing, Men's Clothing, Children's Clothing 472 Dehnhoff WalkOcean Beach, NY 11770 Hamptons West $ 3 reviews Home Decor, Antiques, Accessories (631) 626-8300 30 Railroad AveSayville, NY 11782 T J Maxx image/svg+xml $$ 4 reviews Department Stores (631) 348-6778 1820 Veterans HwyIslandia, NY 11749 Deep End of the Sandbox $ 21 reviews Used, Vintage & Consignment, Video Game Stores, Vinyl Records (631) 676-3130 650 Portion RdHolbrook, NY 11741 Zimmerman's Home $ 2 reviews Furniture Stores (631) 483-2031 57 Garfield AveEast Islip, NY 11730 Ollie's Bargain Outlet $ 4 reviews Discount Store, Toy Stores, Home & Garden (631) 320-5172 323 Middle Country RdCoram, NY 11727