Oakdale, NY Listings Dining Shopping Leisure Highest Rated Dining The Shed Restaurant - West Sayville $$ 449 reviews American, Bars, Comfort Food (631) 750-9191 21 Main StWest Sayville, NY 11796 View $$$ 566 reviews Seafood, Bars, Venues & Event Spaces (631) 589-2694 3 Consuelo PlOakdale, NY 11769 Oakdale Brew House $$ 139 reviews New American, Bars, Pizza (631) 212-1255 927A Montauk HwyOakdale, NY 11769 Parlor House Grill $$ 145 reviews New American (631) 438-0733 298 W Main StSayville, NY 11782 The Snapper Inn $$$ 293 reviews New American, Seafood (631) 589-0248 500 Shore DrOakdale, NY 11769 Mannino's Restaurant and Lounge $$$ 287 reviews Italian, Lounges (631) 218-0909 1575 Montauk HwyOakdale, NY 11769 Off The Block Kitchen & Meats $$ 533 reviews Breakfast & Brunch, Meat Shops, New American (631) 573-6655 501 N Main StSayville, NY 11782 The LakeHouse $$$ 712 reviews New American (631) 666-0995 135 Maple AveBay Shore, NY 11706 The Sayville Inn $$ 112 reviews Seafood, American, Burgers (631) 319-6774 199 Middle RdSayville, NY 11782 Sweet Jane $ 42 reviews Cocktail Bars, New American, Breakfast & Brunch 64 E Main StBay Shore, NY 11706 The Wayward Kitchen & Cocktails $ 109 reviews Desserts, Salad, Cocktail Bars (631) 567-6345 98 Main StSayville, NY 11782 Cafe Joelle $$ 219 reviews New American, Bars, Cafes (631) 589-4600 45 Foster AveSayville, NY 11782 La Villetta II $$ 145 reviews Italian (631) 676-7775 3505 Veterans Memorial HwyRonkonkoma, NY 11779 Fatty McGees $ 54 reviews Bars, Chicken Wings, Sandwiches (631) 581-9868 138 Connetquot AveEast Islip, NY 11730 Dark Horse Coffee & Kitchen $ 70 reviews Coffee & Tea, Breakfast & Brunch, Bakeries (631) 256-6988 4836 Sunrise HwySayville, NY 11782 The Cull House $$ 259 reviews Seafood, Wine Bars, Beer Bar (631) 563-1546 75 Terry StSayville, NY 11782 Canz $ 44 reviews Sports Bars, American, Beer Bar (631) 256-5575 4780 Sunrise Hwy S Service RdBohemia, NY 11716 NOCO $$$ 252 reviews New American (631) 250-9600 429 North Country RdSaint James, NY 11780 Kingston's Fish Market $$ 36 reviews Seafood (631) 589-0567 134 Atlantic AveWest Sayville, NY 11796 Village Idiot Irish Pub $$ 71 reviews American, Irish Pub (631) 573-6633 1487 Montauk HwyOakdale, NY 11769 Zest $$ 149 reviews New American, Barbeque, Pizza (631) 647-4497 298 W Main StBayshore Floyd's $$ 21 reviews American, Breakfast & Brunch Bayview WalkFire Island, NY 11980 Mēna Mediterranean $ 10 reviews Mediterranean, Pizza, Tapas/Small Plates (631) 750-6900 183 West Main StSayville, NY 11782 Hidden Oak Cafe $$ 62 reviews Desserts, Salad, Sandwiches (631) 277-3895 440 Montauk HwyGreat River, NY 11739